I really loved this story. I can't give it 5 stars though because I cried at the end. If I hadn't gotten the version with the Coda (an after thought epilogue of sorts), I might have only given 3 stars. It's not that the ending is wrong or unbelievable, I just didn't like it. I wanted the two men to have more. So, while I get why it ended the way it did, I wish it could have ended differently. I didn't expect an HEA, I mean there's no way they were getting that and the book not delve into the supernatural. But several more years of HFN would have worked for me.